copyright © Wartime Heritage Association 2012-2024
Website hosting courtesy of Register.com - a web.com company
Wartime Heritage
ASSOCIATION
Remembering World War II
Name:
Arthur Churchill Forsyth
Rank:
Lieutenant, Junior Grade
Service Number:
Officer, Third Mate
Service:
SS Zebulon Pike, Merchant Navy
Date of Birth:
September 20, 1922
Place of Birth:
Hantsport, Hants Co., Nova Scotia
Date of Enlistment:
1943
Place of Enlistment:
Unknown
Address at Enlistment:
Baldwin, Nassau, New York
Age at Enlistment:
Unknown
Height:
6 feet, 1 inch
Complexion:
Light
Hair Color:
Brown
Eye Color:
Blue
Date of Death:
January 15, 1945
Age:
22
Cemetery:
Unknown
Arthur Churchill Forsyth was the son of John Stewart Grant Forsyth (1899–1978) and Frances (Churchill)
Forsyth (1901–1942). His father was born in Windsor, in Hants Co., NS; his mother – in the Hantsport / Walton
area of Hants County. Arthur had an older brother Alfred Stuart (1921-1944) and a younger sister Mary
Elizabeth Forsyth (1924–2008).
Arthur’s uncle Lieutenant Alfred Snow Churchill died in the First World War at Vimy Ridge on April 9, 1917,
serving with the Royal Canadian Regiment. Arthur’s brother Lieutenant Alfred S. Forsyth served with the
Princess Louise Fusiliers in the Royal Canadian Infantry Corps in the Second World War and was killed in
action September 29, 1944, age 23. He is interred at the Cassino War Cemetery in Italy.
The family moved to the United States in 1924. Arthur’s mother died in 1942. Arthur was employed as
telephone engineer in the 1930 and 1940. The Forsyth family lived on Staten Island in 1930 but by 1940 had
moved to Hempstead, Long Island.
Arthur C. Forsyth registered for the US Draft on June 30,
1942, in Baldwin, New York. At the time, he was working
for the California Texas Oil Co.
Arthur entered began his merchant navy schooling in 1943
and graduated from the Kings Point United States Merchant
Marine Academy in New York on January 4, 1944. He
signed on as Third Mate aboard the Liberty Ship SS Zebulon
Pike on December 28, 1944 at the port of New York. He
was joined by his academy classmate Edward S. Sherman
who signed on as Second Mate the same day.
Forsyth and Sherman had served aboard the same ship at least twice. Both men signed on as Deck Cadets
aboard the SS Caleb Strong on November 5, 1942. The men signed on as Third and Second Mate,
respectively, aboard the SS Robert F. Stockton at New York, NY on January 20, 1944 and signed off on
November 5, 1944 at
the same port. At the time they signed aboard the Stockton, Forsyth is shown as having six months sea
time while Sherman had seven months time.
The SS Zebulon Pike sailed from New York to Norfolk, VA on January 1, to load cargo. On January 15, 1945
at 1900, Arthur Forsyth and Edward Sherman left their vessel. According to the Zebulon Pike’s Official Log
Book, at 0245 on January 16, the Master was informed by Norfolk Police that the two men apparently
commandeered a taxi, drove the taxi into a body of water and drowned.
According to an account of the incident published on January 16, 1945 in the Norfolk Virginia Pilot, the
taxi containing the two men drove off the Chesapeake and Ohio Terminal at the foot of Brooke Avenue into
the Elizabeth River shortly before 10pm. A rescue boat was on the scene within fifteen minutes of the
accident, but neither man was found in the water. With the assistance of Navy Diver Mack McKesson and a
floating crane, which arrived on the scene at 11:30 p.m., the car was brought to the surface at 12:25 a.m.
At that time Edward Sherman’s body was found to be floating face up outside the car with his coat caught
in the door of the cab. Arthur Forsyth’s body was still inside the cab when the car was brought to the
surface. Edward Sherman’s body was taken to the Ewell & Williamson Funeral Home while Forsyth’s body
was taken to the Cox Funeral Home for preparation for burial. Before the ship sailed on January 18, the
personal effects and wages of Edward Sherman and Arthur Forsyth were left at the U.S. Shipping
Commissioner’s office, for return to their families.*
An article in The Times Dispatch of Richmond, Virginia, Tuesday, January 16, 1945, explains his fate:
NORFOLK Jan 16— (AP) —Two naval officers were drowned last night when a cab in which they were
riding plunged off the pier at the end of Brooke Avenue and sank in the Elizabeth River. The men
were identified by Norfolk police through identification cards in their pockets as: Lieutenant Edward
Stanley Sherman, Jr., USNR, inactive, of 219 Grant St, Port Jefferson, NY, Lieutenant (JG) Arthur C
Forsyth, address unavailable. The men had been attached to the deck department of the Merchant
Marine. The tragedy followed briefly an episode in which two officers commandeered a Yellow Cab in
front of the Atlantic Hotel on Granby Street and disappeared. R F Flannigan reported to police that
he saw a yellow Cab stop on Boush Street near Brooke Avenue and an officer on the rear seat move
into the front seat. Another officer, he said, was driving. The car then was thrown into gear and
driven swiftly through the Boush Street - Brooke Avenue traffic light, while the light was on the red.
Flannigan said the car proceeded down Brooke Avenue toward the water turned left and plunged
overboard. He followed and reported that the cab sank slowly leaving a trail of bubbles. A little
earlier, J H Bryant, driver for the Yellow Cab Company, reported the theft of his cab to police. He
said four officers, one an army officer a member of the air force boarded his cab at the Monticello
Hotel.
‘One Officer Dropped’ - Bryant reported he dropped one of the officers at the Greyhound bus
terminal Granby Street and Brambleton Avenue. The other two, he said, wanted to go to the army
base, and the army officer asked to be taken to the Old Point ferry, at Willoughby, but asked that the
driver stop first at the Atlantic Hotel to pick up his baggage. At the hotel, the driver said, he went in
for the baggage but was refused it and returned to the cab to get the army officer to identify him. As
he left the cab, he reported, one of the men moved from the back seat to the front— a not unusual
procedure. On his return with the army officer, Bryant reported the cab had disappeared.
Lieutenant JG Arthur Churchill Forsyth’s death was ruled an accident. His body was returned to Windsor,
Nova Scotia, on January 20, 1945. His exact place of burial is unknown.
For his service aboard the SS Caleb Strong and SS Robert F. Stockton Arthur C. Forsyth was awarded the
Atlantic War Zone, Pacific War Zone and the Mediterranean-Middle East War Zone Ribbons, the Victory Medal
and the Presidential Testimonial Letter.*
Arthur Churchill Forsyth